• Trusted since 1961
  • Customers rate us 9.4/10
  • 20,000+ shipments per year
NewsAbout usFAQContact

Dealer

en flag icon EN
de flag icon Deutsch(DE) en flag icon English(EN) es flag icon Español(ES) fr flag icon Français(FR) it flag icon Italiano(IT) nl flag icon Nederlands(NL)
Forelle B.V. logo Forelle B.V. logo

Login

0 0
Buying Guides NEW SALE
Baseball/Softball
Baseball/Softball Gloves
Baseball/Softball Bats
Baseball Shoes
Baseball/Softball Balls
Baseball/Softball Helmets
Batting Gloves
Catcher Equipment
Apparel & Protection
Match & Training Equipment
See all products in baseball/softball
American Football
American Football Helmets
Shoulder Pads
American Football Shoes (US size)
American Football Gloves
American Football Balls
Apparel & Protection
Match & Training Equipment
See all products in american football
Fanzone
Brand Merchandise
ELF Merchandise
MLB Merchandise
NBA Merchandise
NFL Merchandise
NHL Merchandise
See all products in fanzone
Other Sports
GAA Rounders
Volleyball
Basketball
Rugby
Ice Hockey
Soccer
Handball
Lacrosse
Cricket
Golf
Racquet Sports
See all products in other sports
  • Baseball/Softball Buying Guides
  • Best First Base Mitts for Baseball and Softball
Back

Buying Guide

Best First Base Mitts for Baseball and Softball

A complete guide to sizing, web styles, and features for every first baseman


Last updated: 28 January 2026 | 4 min read

First base glove

That a first baseman glove is different than other gloves might not be a surprise. All the different features that these glove have might are! If you want to buy a new first baseman glove this guide will help you to learn more about it.

First Basemen might be the most involved position players on the field. They have to catch the receiving throws from other infield players, catching attempts of a pickoff from pitchers and they have to field their position. This asks a lot from a player and even more from their glove. First base gloves look different compared to regular gloves you spot on the field. First Base gloves are also called mitts.


Why a First Base Mitt Is Different?

A First base mitt has no individual finger slots and is one solid piece. This allows for a larger catching surface and better ball control. Only first basemen and catchers are allowed to wear mitts — all other fielders must use standard gloves. This curved, one-piece design provides:

  • A larger catching surface
  • A deeper pocket to handle wild throws
  • Extra padding for protection
  • A shape that helps with scooping low balls

Key features


Sizing

First base mitts are longer than regular gloves, typically sized between 12” and 13”. Common sizes include 12", 12.25", 12.5", 12.75", and 13". The extra length and curved edge make it easier to catch off-target throws and stretch toward incoming balls.

  • ⚠️ Don’t oversize the mitt. A mitt that is too large can reduce control, especially for younger players.
  • For youth players, start with smaller sizes (11.5" – 12") to ensure better handling.
  • Softball mitts are often slightly larger to accommodate the bigger softball (11" to 14" depending on the league).


Webbing & Pocket Depth

First base gloves feature a deeper pocket than other gloves. This allows players to secure more throws and reduces the chance of the ball popping out. Common web styles include:

  • Single Post Web: Most popular for first base, offers visibility and flexibility.
  • Dual Post Web: Offers more structure.
  • Modified H-Web: Seen more in softball, adds durability and control.

These open web styles are ideal for scooping grounders without collecting too much dirt.


First baseman mittb buying Guides

Materials & Stiffness

Just like you need a catcher’s mitt to be sturdy enough to keep catching pitches on a daily basis, you need a first baseman’s mitt to be stiff enough to catch a high number of throws as well. Your mitt should also be flexible enough to scoop ground balls and wild throws and meet basic fielding requirements.


The material of your mitt affects its durability, feel, and break-in time.

  • Leather mitts: Strong, durable, and stiff. Best for frequent use and long-term play.
  • Synthetic mitts: Lightweight and easier to break in, but less durable.


Something you have to check before buying is the varying degrees of wrist adjustments. Some gloves offer an adjustable opening for the wrist. Most of them are in the form of a Velcro Strap, additional lacing or a D-ring. These adjustment options function so that a player can create a more narrower or tighter fit to their hand. All of these different ways of adjustment function the same, but the choice of adjustment is up to the player.


Last but not least, also the most important thing, is personal comfort. Make sure to choose a mitt that makes you feel comfortable and fits comfortable on your hand.

Top Picks for First Base Players

Rawlings R115FBM All-Leather Renegade Youth Series 1st Base Glove 11,5 Inch Rawlings R115FBM All-Leather Renegade Youth Series 1st Base Glove 11,5 Inch
Rawlings R115FBM All-Leather Renegade Youth Series 1st Base Glove 11,5 Inch
99.95
Art. nr. 3603243400001
In stock

View Product
Rawlings PFBDCT Pro Preferred Series Full-Grain Leather First Base Glove 12,5 Inch Rawlings PFBDCT Pro Preferred Series Full-Grain Leather First Base Glove 12,5 Inch
Rawlings PFBDCT Pro Preferred Series Full-Grain Leather First Base Glove 12,5 Inch
129.00
Art. nr. 3603235100001
In stock

View Product
Rawlings R9YPTFM16B Durable All-Leather R9 Series Fastpitch Glove Youth 12 Inch Rawlings R9YPTFM16B Durable All-Leather R9 Series Fastpitch Glove Youth 12 Inch
Rawlings R9YPTFM16B Durable All-Leather R9 Series Fastpitch Glove Youth 12 Inch
209.00
Art. nr. 3603253700001
In stock

View Product

Accessories & Glove Care

To get the most out of your first baseman mitt there are multiple glove accessories available to maintain your glove. 

  • Glove conditioner to soften and protect the leather
  • Break-in kits (glove mallet + wrap)
  • Glove wrap to form the pocket shape
  • Glove bag for safe storage

Regular care extends the life of your glove and improves performance.


JOIN THE CLUB!

Sign up for our newsletter and get a 10% DISCOUNT CODE straight away. You will be the first to hear about new products and special offers for members only.


SIGN UP FOR THE NEWSLETTER
Footer image
  • Riddell brand
  • Rawlings brand
  • Douglas brand
  • Cutters brand
  • Shock Doctor brand
  • SKLZ brand
  • All-Star brand
  • Louisville Slugger brand
  • Easton brand
  • Wilson brand
  • Shoc brand
  • Shruumz brand
  • Kenko brand
  • Rip-it brand
  • Baum brand
  • Gorilla Gold brand
  • GSI brand
  • Evoshield brand
  • Fanatics brand
  • Franklin brand
  • Mcdavid brand
  • Miken brand
  • Jugs brand
  • Lizard Skins brand
  • Markwort brand
  • Mizuno brand
  • Worth brand
  • Xenith brand
  • Trace brand
  • Sportsattack brand

Our products

  • Baseball & Softball

  • American Football

  • Fanzone

  • Other sports

  • Custom Gear

Customer service

  • Buying Guides

  • FAQ

  • Contact

About Forelle

  • About us

  • News

  • Impressum

  • Sitemap

forelle's logo

Marie Curieweg 2
6045 GH Roermond
The Netherlands

+31 475 33 45 60

[email protected]

© 2026 - Forelle B.V.
  • PayPal
  • iDeal
  • Creditcard
  • Klarna Pay Later
  • Bancontact
  • Belfius
  • KBC
  • EPS
  • Apple Pay
Privacy Policy Disclaimer Terms and Conditions
×
Google reviews

Baseball/Softball

Baseball/Softball

Baseball/Softball Gloves
Baseball/Softball Bats
Baseball Shoes
Baseball/Softball Balls
Baseball/Softball Helmets
Batting Gloves
Catcher Equipment
Apparel & Protection
Match & Training Equipment
See all products in baseball/softball

American Football

American Football

American Football Helmets
Shoulder Pads
American Football Shoes (US size)
American Football Gloves
American Football Balls
Apparel & Protection
Match & Training Equipment
See all products in american football

Fanzone

Fanzone

Brand Merchandise
ELF Merchandise
MLB Merchandise
NBA Merchandise
NFL Merchandise
NHL Merchandise
See all products in fanzone

Other Sports

Other Sports

GAA Rounders
Volleyball
Basketball
Rugby
Ice Hockey
Soccer
Handball
Lacrosse
Cricket
Golf
Racquet Sports
See all products in other sports
Buying Guides
NEW
SALE
NewsAbout usFAQContact

Dealer

en flag icon

Login

Welcome back
Forgot password?

Don't have an account yet?

Sign up and enjoy the benefits of your account.

  • Manage your wishlist

  • View order history, status and much more

  • Tax-free shopping outside the EU!

Create an account

Questions, advice or need help?

+31 (0)475 - 334560
Available from Monday to Friday from 8:00 to 17:00 and Saturday from 8:00 to 16:00. Or feel free to send an e-mail to [email protected]

Almost yours

Edit basket Continue checkout
Hang tight, we're getting things ready for you...